Friday, February 10, 2006

The kindest cut?

news @ nature.com-Cutting the risk of HIV-Male circumcision protects both women and men from infection.

The above story suggests that, especially in Africa, routine circumcision could make a big effect on the HIV rates.

This will send the anti-circumcision crowd into a frenzy of denial. The absolute fanaticism with which circumcision is criticised by some groups is really amazing. There is even a lot of stuff (about 138,000 Google hits) on the web about foreskin restoration (a lot of stretching involved.)

All seems to me to be ridiculously out of proportion, especially as there would seem to be kinder ways of performing a circumcision now than the old ways. But medicine is the subject of fads and disagreements just as much as other fields of human endeavour, and in Australia I believe it is quite difficult to find a doctor who will do one now unless it is clearly medically needed.

No comments: