Thursday, March 17, 2011

Pure idiocy

What does the media think it is doing, promoting this schoolyard bullying incident that has "gone viral"?

Everyone knows that the videoing of fights amongst school kids and posting them up on Facebook has become a large part of a bullying/cyberbullying vicious cycle. Apparently, this particular one was pulled from Facebook/Youtube pretty quickly, only to appear in the Fairfax media yesterday. What was Fairfax thinking? It was giving more publicity to a video that did not deserve it, and has only led to further appalling consequences.

The reason for it being pulled from Facebook (or Youtube?)was not clear to me, but from the Sky News report noted on this page of the Daily Telegraph, it might have had something to do with the fact that the idiots who posted it put a telephone number at the end as being the one for the young bully's home, and encouraged people to ring and abuse him and his family.

Turns out the number was for the home of a couple of old folk who have nothing to do with this at all, and received many highly abusive calls; some from overseas.

So, you might say: good on the Daily Telegraph for including this corrective.

Um, no, wait a minute. The body of the Daily Telegraph article says that the mother of the bully was interviewed on Channel 7 Today Tonight and "demanded an apology from the victim":

"We don't need this posted everywhere," she said. "I would like him to apologise."
This Daily Telegraph report was picked up in the (second) post on the story by right wing Anerican site Hot Air. Given that their first story was full of comments with gushing praise for the victim having had his revenge on the bully (with barely a handful of comments noting that it was pure good luck that he didn't accidentally kill the bully and end up at real risk of a trial for manslaughter) this revelation of the mother wanting an apology was too much:
Listen up, you worthless brood mare: if you raised your kids not to be bullies, they wouldn’t get bodyslammed. Now f**k off, because there’s a good chance you’re going to be demanding another apology in the future from the judge that puts your stupid brat behind bars.
That was a comment by "Madisonconservative". Yes, there is so much to admire on the Right of American politics at the moment.

One small problem: go look at the video of the story from Today Tonight (I am not sure how long it will be available) and it appears clear that the Daily Telegraph has misquoted the mother. She is referring to her own boy apologising.

The mother in fact comes across very well in the Today Tonight story. She is very embarrassed by her son's actions, and becomes emotional when she complains about it being splattered all over the internet. Who can blame her? She considers her son has made a big mistake and paid for it; it doesn't need to follow him indefinitely on line.

Now, hopefully the mother has more sense than to be reading the internet to see what people are saying about this. But The Daily Telegraph has had the uncorrected story up all day - and unless they have seen some part of the Channel 7 video that we haven't - it is a clear mistake which should be corrected immediately. If she is receiving abusive phone calls, and given what happened earlier in this story, that would seem very likely, I hope she sues the Daily Telegraph.

The Daily Telegraph Facebook page has had a comment up for 7 hours pointing out they are mis-quoting the mother: why is the webpage uncorrected?

As for the continued simple minded praise and cheering that is coming from websites about this video: they continue to disgust me.

UPDATE:

The Daily Telegraph is featuring an apology this morning, but it's hardly profuse:

IN an article published in The Daily Telegraph yesterday headlined "Bully's angry mum wants victim to apologise", it was written that bully Ritchard Gale's mother Tina wanted her son's victim to apologise for slamming her son to the ground.

But she had, in fact, said she wanted her son to apologise to his victim.

The Daily Telegraph apologises for the error.

What's more, on line, it appears above the original story of the incident from (at least) a couple of days ago, not the story in which the paper defames the mother! In fact, as you can see from the screenshot, the apology is the most popular story; but the second most popular story is still the (uncorrected when you click on it) report from yesterday:


Clearly, as at the time I write this, there may still be hundreds (thousands?) of people following Tweeted, emailed or Facebooked links to the incorrect story, and they will not see the correction.

When I posted last evening, I noted there had been a message on the Daily Tele's Facebook page for at least 7 hours telling them they had got it wrong. It also looks like some of the commenters took to emailing the Tele to point out the mistake, as this poor woman was copping abuse from all over the world for something she never did.

The apology seems to have gone on line at midnight local time, and yet, as I say, the link to the original wrong story still does not carry the apology.

Hey, Daily Telegraph: look at the title of this post. It's for you.

UPDATE 2: I see that Hot Air has a large "correction" now - although it is not as clear as it could be:

Update: Corrected — bully’s mom wants son to apologize

Whose son? Why not try this - Corrected - bully's mom wants her son to apologize.

Idiots.

UPDATE 3: what did it take? A phone call from a lawyer? I see that sometime in the last hour or two, the Daily Telegraph finally made their incorrect story page disappear. Congratulations, and where's your cheque book?

UPDATE 4: the Daily Telegraph has dropped the apology from its front page already. (It is still on the site, if you know where to find it.) Barely 12 hours is considered enough to give the apology prominence, is it?

UPDATE 5: Pssst: Daily Tele. Your Facebook entry for this story is still headed:
The mother of a school bully whose video has gone viral wants the victim to apologise. See her side of the story.
And the only link is to the now removed story. Try putting a link to the apology and correction, you incompetents.

5 comments:

Phil Harvey said...

I can't get over how many people are taking the newspaper article at face value and not watching the video (or reading the other comments. Every time I mentioned on the Facebook page how wrong the article is, more people would leave comments bagging the mother.

George said...

It is obvious that this is nothing more than a stunt to get page views and visits to their website.

I myself, tried calling and sending them messages telling them that story was incorrect within an hour that it was up.

It does not take over a day to correct something like this, and they were blatantly leaving it up on purpose when they saw the hits to that page climb virally.

This corporation should be made to pay for their actions, it is inconcievably dispicable to purposely defame an innocent person in order to attain more visits to their site.

I wish the mother sues the daily telegraph - have some lawyers look into the whole story and see that given the amount of corrections people sent to them, and the time it took them for them to correct the article, while all the meantime they sit back and watch their hits double, triple, quadruple - taking no action until an acceptable amount of time after!

Phil Harvey said...

I couldn't agree more George. Something else that isn't helping the situation is the fact that the creator of the "Casey the Punisher' Facebook page has left up a post with a link to the now removed article. The post asks the question "THE MOTHER OF THE BULLY WANTS CASEY TO APOLOGIZE! WHAT DO YOU THINK?" People who haven't yet realised that the Daily Telegraph article is a beat-up are still leaving comments full of hatred directed at the bully's mother. If the owner of the page had any decency they would remove the post and all it's disgusting comments. I have a feeling that whoever it is is trying to stir up more trouble.

Steve said...

Phil, I saw your follow up comment on email, but it did not turn up here for some reason.

I think I have heard someone else say that comments to blogspot blogs sometimes go astray. Just wanted you to know I didn't stop it appearing.

Phil Harvey said...

No worries Steve, I would only expect to see that happen on the Daily Telegraph's site :-)
What I can't believe is that the Tele still have the post referring to the article (although the article itself is removed) on their Facebook page - along with all the comments condemning the mother. The same goes for the "Casey the Punisher" Facebook page, which has a post titled "THE MOTHER OF THE BULLY WANTS CASEY TO APOLOGIZE! WHAT DO YOU THINK?" Attached to that are hundreds of disgusting comments, all directed at the mother - and more are still being added to it every day.
I think the whole thing is disgusting!