Saturday, November 10, 2018

Melbourne and violence

Melbourne seems to be having a particularly bad run with immigrant related violence over the past few years.   It would seem that yesterday's inner city attack by a radicalised Muslim could have been much worse if explosions from gas bottles had occurred.   But then again, why was the vehicle burning like that in the first place?   Were some gas bottles opened?   In any case, when I saw the video of people filming the scene, I though to myself that there is no way I would have hung around that close to the vehicle in case there was an explosion.   Must have been worrying the police trying to catch the guy, too. 

I half-watched the Four Corners show this week on the issue of African youth gang violence, and the degree to which it is or isn't being blown out of proportion.   I feel a bit of a fence sitter on the issue:  the show was good in that it didn't shy away from personalising the story both from the perspective of victims, and of young black guys unfairly caught up in the backlash.   It's one of those cases where  you can say both that it's silly to pretend it isn't a problem but still dislike the way the Murdoch media treats it as a problem.

Anyway, I've long been curious as to why this seems to centre on Melbourne.  Some Brisbane suburbs are known for the African immigrants but as far as I know there is no significant issue with youth gangs here.   And now that I check, Sydney had nearly as many Sudanese migrants as Melbourne, at least in 2011. 

Melbourne is a great place for eating and for people with ridiculous obsession with sports;  it's now just so-so for cultural pursuits, I reckon.   But all of those things are indoors (I'm counting sitting in a stadium as indoors) and I assume of marginal interest to current African youth.   If you aren't involved in those three things during the long, grey winters of that city, I think it probably is a pretty boring place.   Sydney and Brisbane don't have the same winter grey doldrums that Melbourne has.

So yeah, I'm going out on a limb and blaming gang violence on crappy weather.  But as time goes on and younger family members get absorbed in that Melbourne Borg of the footy and cricket (God help them), it will reduce. 

Hey, it's a theory.

6 comments:

TimT said...

What. Melbourne weather is fantastic. We need more winter, not less.

BTW, it's the super hot dog days of summer that traditionally have caused rioting and violence around the world....!

Steve said...

I think you need to move to Tasmania. Or New Zealand.

By the way, if the heat and riot connection is true, shouldn't hotter Sydney (or Brisbane) have more African youth gangs on the rampage?

Anonymous said...

'Hey, it's a theory.'

In the US Sudanese gang crime has been most concentrated in Omaha despite having larger Sudanese refugee populations elsewhere. Look for factors common to refugee resettlement Omaha and Melbourne.

Steve said...

Maybe Omaha weather is like Melbourne's? :)

Apart from the snow...

TimT said...

Oh Sydney have had their fair share of riots. Cronulla. And that riot out in the housing estate beyond Parramatta. Was it Macquarie Fields?

Steve said...

True. You make me feel like Brisbane is missing out...