I give Roger Scruton credit for being the rarest of things: a clearly right wing intellectual who takes a precautionary approach to climate change, and advocates taxation as a means to address it. (According to this review of one of his books - by Peter Singer no less - Scruton advocates a carbon consumption tax, even though it appears rather impractical to put an accurate figure for such on imported goods.)
So what's Roger doing coming out here and being the headline act, so to speak, of yet another IPA "Western Civilisation Symposium" in May this year? Unless these symposiums are a bit of a money spinner for the far from poor IPA, it's hard to see why they are running another one. You can tell from the comments at Catallaxy that the attendees are all more than likely already members of the IPA who are simply attending - and paying - to get the warm inner glow of hearing what they already believe, and to have drinks with people who think Labor and Unions are appalling people, darling, (and causing the downfall of the once great glorious West).
It keeps them off the street for a weekend, I suppose, and from making inane comments at Catallaxy.
But, does Roger know of the IPA's starring role within Australian politics at promoting not only skepticism over political responses to climate change, but disbelief in climate change per se?
If he is genuine in his concern about a political need to take action about it (as he obviously is if he is promoting a tax as the answer), why would his lend his support to this organisation?
Unfortunately, there is a precedent for this behaviour. Scruton was caught out as a handsomely paid shill for tobacco companies just over a decade ago. What an embarrassment that turned out to be, and one would have thought that he might be more careful about his associations in future. But then, the Institute of Paid Advocacy and him obviously have something in common.
Now, I assume the symposium will not touch climate change, but even so - if there is any prospect that this event is a money spinner for the IPA, or even if he is just helping raise its public profile, he's helping support an organisation that deserves his disrespect and complete disdain if he is genuine about climate change.
I see that Scruton is also doing a Quadrant event. Similar comments apply.
No comments:
Post a Comment