Friday, August 11, 2023

In today's example of how not to win a referendum...


Some in the comments following have noticed his twitter account heading, and not taken it well:


I never liked the guy, anyway, but if  he wants to be an advertisement (ironically or not) for the idea that the whole reconciliation/treaty process is just an exercise about extracting money (a position actual racists have argued for decades), I guess he's free to do so.  

Amongst a lot of comments by some who no doubt would count as racist, there is this, which seems fair:

And while I don't know that this describes the situation for all "No" voters, this doesn't seem too unreasonable either:
 


Yes:  the thing is, the Yes campaign often promotes the idea that it is essential because (as Dan Andrews recently put it) "things work best when government listens".

But the issue is surely, at the fundamental level, not that governments "don't listen", but who they listen to amongst the range of aboriginal views often expressed on contentious issues.   

If the Voice is meant to solve that problem - formalising the "official" body who governments need to take advice from - the referendum still looks weakly justified because of the rambling, bureaucratic and inconclusive waffle that Langton and others came up with in describing how the representative body would work.   


2 comments:

  1. I have not read anyone saying people who advocate no are racist. Then the no campaign put out a racist cartoon in the AFR that Bill Leak would have been proud of.

    People such as Mundine and Price are quite poor BUT it doesn't matter. It is far too easy to make fearful claims.

    People will vote against it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. The WA Heritage Act, even repealed, is a disaster for the Yes vote.
    The 290 billion litigation for "spiritual damage" is a ...
    The extra 26 pages of "notes" is a ...
    The early arguments about No voters "being on the wrong side of history" were a ...
    Thomas Mayo's demands to "pay the rent" are ...
    This example is a ...

    What a way to completely stuff up a campaign. I am at a loss to understand how they thought demanding so much before the vote was a good idea.

    I imagine Albanese is now ruing his decision to make this such a big issue in the midst of a cost-of-living crisis that the government has no solutions for, issued a budget that was unimaginative, boring, and did very little to help the general population, and we are now facing a recession.

    The ideas cabinet is obviously is empty. This government has obsessed too much with the referendum and has no solutions for the nationwide problems that are becoming worse. I wanted Labor to win because I couldn't stand another Morrison term but this government is so impotent it will be lucky to have another term.

    ReplyDelete