Thursday, October 08, 2026

A minor example of AI sounding like much more than a word prediction machine

I just asked Claude.ai about my impressions of Lolita, so far, given that I am only about a third of the way through the book.   I pointed out that progress (only read a third), and asked whether it seemed fair to call Humbert (the protagonist narrator) a sociopath.

Claude didn't think that fitted the character all that well, and I pushed back a bit and it conceded a bit, and then I moved on to ask about the Kubrick movie version, as my impression from the trailer (and perhaps what I had read about it a long time ago) was that it was blackly humorous, more so than the book.  

Claude's answer started as follows:

Your impression is right. Kubrick's 1962 film leans into satire, and much of the humor comes from Peter Sellers in a role you haven't properly reached in the book yet, so I'll say no more. James Mason plays Humbert as prim, frazzled, and absurdly put-upon, and Shelley Winters' Charlotte is played for comic excess, which fits the book's mockery of her. 

This may be a minor point to some, but doesn't the way it does not want to ruin my reading of the book by disclosing where the story goes feel very human-like?   

 

5 comments:

  1. No, there is plenty of literature in reviews with the warning "spoiler alert".

    ReplyDelete
  2. Spoiler alerts are usually followed by - the spoiler.
    It didn't do that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Spoiler alerts are a warning that sometimes comes with the admonition don't read on.

      Delete
  3. Don't get me wrong - I'm not wanting to overstate its significance. I just interested in what things LLM AI says that give off particular "consciousness" vibes, and why.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's where it becomes murky. It seems we have forgotten about the Turing Test. I think many current bots could pass the Turing Test and it would take very specific challenges to unmask the bot. Then we come to Searle's Chinese room concept.

      Delete