An extremely annoying feature of the world of conspiracy mongering is the never ending shifting of the goal posts, and insisting that it is up to the victim of invented stories to prove it isn't true, as this ridiculous case of "Talarico was in an Ohio mental hospital" shows.
First, I will let Claude give the timeline:
Talarico disclosed the flu diagnosis himself on September 30, during a virtual event. The rest of the sequence, drawing on the reporting I found:
- Sept 26: His last publicly documented event, according to The Post Millennial. thepostmillennial
- Sept 29: His last in-person campaign event, in New York City, per Mediaite. mediaite
- Sept 30: He joined a U.S. Hispanic Business Council event by Zoom and said he’d been diagnosed with flu at an urgent care clinic in Dallas. He had been due to attend in person. sacurrentnews5cleveland
- Early October: Paxton’s campaign sent out press releases about his absence, and the campaign then confirmed the flu to the San Antonio Current, saying he’d be back on the trail soon. sacurrent
- Wednesday (Oct 7, by my count): Paxton led a crowd in chanting “Where is James Talarico?” while speaking at a Trump rally. Trump also called Talarico “missing in action” on Truth Social. mediaitenews5cleveland
- Thursday (Oct 8): Spokesperson JT Ennis said Talarico had come down with the flu after more than 100 events and would return that weekend. The Paxton campaign demanded “proof of life.” NewsweekNewsweek
- Friday (Oct 9): He reappeared at the Austin City Limits music festival. mediaite
- Oct 14: He is booked for a CNN town hall
The claim he was in a mental hospital was supported by ONE piece of alleged evidence - an apparent phone call of a poor staffer trying to be helpful to the lying MAGA influencer, who after repeatedly saying there was no one of that name in the facility, then seemingly indicated that he (or she - I think she referred to Talarico that way) had been discharged that evening.
That statement sounded very equivocal and everything (including her not apparently checking for the "code" that was meant to ensure she really was talking to a relative) sounded very much like she was just wanting to get this guy off the phone after not being able to find any actual patient of that name. (And in the full phone call, it was the influencer who suggested to her that maybe he had been discharged.)
What's now been established is that on the day of the alleged call Talarico had already been seen out and about in Texas - he couldn't have been discharged interstate "that evening". And the facility itself denies on Twitter that he has ever been treated there. Talarico denies he has ever even been in the state of Ohio.
So what do the MAGA conspiracy addled brain now do now? Try to claim it's still a mystery where he was for 9 days.
This bit of news then from the New York Times won't make any difference:
The New York Times reviewed time-stamped images from a security camera at Mr. Talarico’s home, which were provided by his campaign on the condition they not be published for security reasons. The images showed Mr. Talarico around the exterior of the home and at its entrances between Oct. 1 and Oct. 8.
And of course Musk promoted the conspiracy too. He's appalling.
stupid is as stupid does.
ReplyDeleteI lost it when JC posted something about that. I put an extract from the institution which denied he had been there.
ReplyDeleteThe US situation rhetoric wise is hopeless. The same stupidities also exist on the Left but are much more restrained and pushed by independent social media outlets rather than political figures.
The GOP has to get smashed. Trump is poison for that country and, perhaps too optimistically, there is a growing recognition that he must be shut down if not removed from office.
After the midterms I am going to repeatedly plaster the Cat with insults proclaiming how stupid, hypocritical and dishonest so many there have been. I've already had one belt a while ago. That was a warm up.