Back in 2010 I posted about the remarkable parapsychology experiments of Daryl Bem which seemed to establish a small but consistent effect of precognition. The experiments were very clever, and rather odd in many respects. (The most successful one involved guessing behind which curtain was an erotic photo! But I guess testing for precognition is always going to feel weird.)
In 2012, I noted that one attempt at replicating the experiments had failed. (See, I am very fair.)
Now, Dean Radin reports that there has in fact been many experimenters who have had successful replication.
The full paper pre-print detailing this can be downloaded from here. Although the statistical analysis talk is hard for a lay person to follow in full detail, the conclusion of successful replication seems very clear. The paper's background discussion, and its concluding sections about implications for future science research, make it a very interesting read.
I guess one has to wait to see what the skeptics have to say about this (Radin is pessimistic they will ever be convinced), but this appears to me to very significant.
Update: the original experiments were hotly contested by skeptic types, and early failure to replicate were treated as dismissing it all. Bem himself spoke about the debunkers here.
Thanks for this update Steve. I have a casual interest in this area and have never been prepared to dismiss all parapsychology as junk.
ReplyDelete