So, last night we finished watching the Netflix series Barbarians, and it was quite a bloody spectacle. It no doubt was the cause of a dream in which I was about to be beheaded by some black clad executioner at, of all places, Disneyland. (I had also seen a news story about Hong Kong Disneyland during the day, so there is a reason.) It started with me glumly accepting my fate, only to start worrying that it was really going to hurt a lot before I lost consciousness because his axe didn't look sharp, and arguing that I would prefer to be shot. (Finally, I realised that I hadn't been convicted of a crime, only accused of one, so I didn't deserve execution at all. I think I successfully convinced him as I woke up.)
Anyway: I went into watching the series only seeing that it had quite good reviews. I had a vague idea that it was based loosely on real events, but did not bother, until now, to check that out. (It's always best to leave reading the real story until after a movie or series is finished, as the degree of invention is often a tad disappointing - especially if the events are particularly well documented.)
I did like the show overall - and part of the fun of watching it was trying to work out whether it was pandering to German nationalism, or not. I mean, it did paint the Romans as being pretty terrible and ruthless in their local rule, but on the other hand, it made the Germanic tribes look very technologically inferior, unpleasantly fractious, and much more into religious "woo" than the Romans. But the whole story is about a successful underdog attack on the Romans, so put that into the "pro-German" column.
Now that I have gone looking for historical commentary, at the top of the Google list is this fantastically detailed assessment on a blog by a young American Midwest university history student who seemingly really knows his stuff. If you have finished the series, I strongly recommend reading Spencer McDaniel's post.
To my surprise, the series is basically much more accurate than I expected. Sure, it has added fictional details (including ones about a couple of key relationships); but overall, I am quite delighted to read that the show's producers have obviously taken way more care than is common in adding historically accurate details - or when inventing details, at least making them possible and not entirely implausible.
I also had no idea of the nationalistic importance of the story of the battle of the Teutoburg Forest, but Spencer explains all of that as well. His blog Tales of Times Forgotten, seems to have quite a lot of interesting content, actually.
I see that a lot of people have discussed the show's accuracy. Another nerdy guy has made a Youtube video about it, and he seems overall to be quite impressed as well.
So, well done, everyone.
And all the Wodan talk in the show makes me keener to see The Ring Cycle at the end of this year. (It was COVID delayed last year.)