I see that GTA VI is receiving some enthusiastic reviews (gawd, the New York Times with its "it will steal your heart, it's so romantic" review seems a bit OTT to me), but also it already has some clips on X by people showing graphic scenes of violence, particularly against women, and consequent questioning of its moral worth. (One tweet complains - and I don't know how true this is - that the game prevents the shooting up of a LGBT nightclub, as if that's a disappointment!)
While I am (no doubt) significantly older than 99% of players, I do find it a bit cringe that a game that allows roleplaying participation in a garish criminal world is so embraced by so many adults. Sure, it doesn't (generally!) turn people into criminals, but I don't understand why more adults don't see it as morally degrading that it allows many players to live out a criminal life fantasy.
I can see the counterarguments from a mile away: do I have a similar problem with movies that allow immersion in violent criminal underworlds? If I have enjoyed one of those movies, this is just another way to experience a story, so why should I have something against that?
As it happens, I do have a problem with a lot of criminal underworld movies. I think Pulp Fiction and most of Tarantino's oeuvre is objectionable, as is (probably, I don't watch it) much of Guy Ritchie's stuff. Criminal underworld being made "cool" is not something I have ever endorsed. (On the other hand, movies where there is violence and tension in the fight against criminals - such as The Untouchables - is not exactly problematic for me, although I still don't enjoy extreme realism in bloodletting.)
And I think that the active participation element of computer games is what makes them more objectionable than watching the equivalent on movies. Isn't that a reasonable moral objection? Isn't the fact that it seems to have been reported often that young school shooters were big fans of first person shooting games a reasonable cause for concern?
Anyway, I have just realised that there are comments to the NYT review which give me some reassurance that I'm not the only one with issues about such games. For example:
It's an interactive porn/snuff film right? That's what it looks like from screenshots anyway. Apparently it's heart warming? ...
Or:
I know it's my judgement…
An Op-Ed in the Times yesterday decried the harsh "levels of violence" a player has to move through in order to be successful in the game.
Some very ugly descriptions of cruelty and vicious killing rendered with the latest graphic realism.
Reading about it all made me wonder about my fellow humans.
Especially since I have to encounter some of these players in public or, worse, while driving!
I avoid most gratuitously violent movies…
The worst content I see usually involves Bugs Bunny sabotaging Daffy Duck or Wile E. Coyote going off a cliff.
Maybe try that.
Though your mom will wonder why you're watching cartoons.
Or:
Had no idea until yesterday’s NYT article of the horrible cruelty depicted in GTA. That so many people in the world are drawn to watching this is disturbing. And their rationalizations make it worse. I don’t care how educated you are or what you do for a living, I think there is something very wrong with wanting to see this kind of cruelty, even on a screen. Sorry.
Well, I had missed yesterday's article about the cruelty in the game. Guess I should read that now, to feel more indignant!

%20_%20X.png)
%20_%20X.png)


