Saturday, February 01, 2014

Sinclair Davidson doesn't know there was a Coastwatch Oz TV show; verbals a Senator he still leaves being called a "bush pig"at his blog

With a headline to his post "Television isn't always real", Sinclair Davidson is clearly going along with the instant Right wing meme set up by his minions that Senator Hanson-Young was referring to the fictional Sea Patrol TV series in the question she asked yesterday.  In fact, the name of that show was said by one of public servants (and, if you ask me, he was acting in quite a smart ass fashion with his question.) The Senator indicated that was not the show in the way she responded.  She specifically referred to it as dealing with "fishing boats and so forth".  As I recall, Sea Patrol did not routinely deal with "fishing boat" stories; a recent reality TV show did.  (They also stopped making Sea Patrol a few years ago now.)

Coastwatch Oz, which Sinclair Davidson can watch on line here, was the recent reality TV show I believe she was referring to.  (Or, possibly, she may have been thinking of the New Zealand version of the same show, thinking from a quick viewing of it that it was Australian.)

Sinclair Davidson has also acknowledged that he read my earlier post re the Senator being referred to as a "bush pig"at his blog.  He is not concerned to moderate that comment.

He appears pretty often on ABC radio and TV.  He's a Professor at RMIT.  Why does no one ask him about his policy for what he will leave up on his blog?

Update:  I see Andrew Bolt, as is his wont, has merely copied the Catallaxy story and continued the verballing of the Senator.  Why Bolt doesn't just write directly for the blog, given that his ignorance on certain topics well qualifies him, I don't know.

Update 2:   I didn't actually realise when I first wrote this post, but Coastwatch Oz first screened on Channel 7 on the evening of 30 January.   The Senate hearing in question was on 31 January.   If anything, this make it all the more likely that the Senator was referring to the show, not 3 or 4 year old episodes of Sea Patrol.

I also have to point out, in fairness, that Latika Burke also went along with the "she was thinking Sea Patrol was real" meme.  Bad Latika.

Update 3:  in fairness to Bolt, he has updated his post with a reader comment pointing out the Coastwatch Oz explanation.  Will Catallaxy?  Probably not.

And besides:  clearly, Andrew Bolt does not care about the lack of moderation of "bush pig" at Catallaxy, otherwise he would not be recommending people to the blog.

What a hypocrite, when he posts continually about how objectionable he finds Left wing commentary on blogs and twitter.

Update 4:  the Senator complains to the Daily Telegraph that she was indeed referring to Coastwatch Oz, not Sea Patrol, which was not mentioned by her.  Tim Blair still being a smart arse about it.

Does Catallaxy update it's post?   No, of course not.  In fact, his last update tries to reinforce that she was referring to Sea Patrol.   "Bush pigs" don't deserve corrections, obviously.

11 comments:

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Steve said...

Haven't readers worked out yet that I just delete comments with unacceptable language in them?

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Steve said...

Oh, very funny, deleted comment maker.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

When you've lost m0nty ...
http://loadeddogma.blogspot.com.au/2014/02/out-of-mouths-of-babes-and-sucklings.html?showComment=1391234937592#c6869727133141528735

Steve said...

I take your last comment as confirmation that you're from Catallaxy, anonymous.

Anonymous said...

You can't think for poor SHY or guess what she was referring to, however the video does show she was asked which show and she couldn't answer and seemed confused and fluttered her eyes and said "about fishing boats and so forth". So she was asking a questioning senate estimates providing an example that she was unable to recall. That on its own shows she is hopeless. Can you dispute when asked she was unable to respond to her very own reference?

Steve said...

The criticism of "she couldn't cite which show she meant" is entirely different from "ha ha! she didn't know Sea Patrol was fiction!"

Anonymous said...

I think you'll find the defence of SHY is misplaced.
CoastwatchOz isn't about border patrols, it shows the NSW Police and Fisheries activities.
It does not promote the Australian border protection services as claimed by SHY.
If she meant to reference CoastwatchOz her commentary proves that she hadn't watched it and was woefully unprepared.

Steve said...

Go back to my previous comment.

It is legitimate to say her Coastwatch OZ example is not relevant to what the Federal government does - it appears to only have State co-operation (as the State police force seems to feature in it.)

That is fine.

What I am objecting to is the "verballing" of her on the issue of her thinking Sea Patrol was reality TV.