Saturday, July 29, 2017

Comedy and the public service

I usually watch Utopia, but I've never been 100% sure whether to fully endorse it.  (Well, I did say I was enjoying it back in 2014.  Perhaps my doubts are growing.)

It does have good acting, I think - with the possible exception of Rob Sitch, who has a very limited range - and some lines can be sharp and amusing, if not lol funny.

But the problem with the show is that it's still mainly a satire of Public Service managerialism (and secondarily, of political obsession with spin), but it feels that the heights of faith in managerialism are well in the past, perhaps by two or three decades now.

The result is that I never am sure whether the satire is accurate, or dated.  Certainly, last week's episode, featuring the hoops that the female lead (I don't really remember any character's name) had to go through to get a promotion her boss had promised her struck me as relatively accurate from what I had heard of the public service from a friend in it - back in the 1980's.   (And by the way, the female actor who was the HR person inventing procedural roadblocks was really good in a well written role, I thought.) 

I'm not sure how anyone on the outside, who no longer knows anyone in the public service, finds out how the character of public service life has changed in recent decades.  But I hope it has...   





5 comments:

not trampis said...

It is a great comedy.

Anonymous said...

Steve you wouldn't know if the satire was accurate because the only workplace you've ever been in is Centrelink when you pick up your special hardship payments.

not trampis said...

JC you have always been sore about paying all that money for ESL classes and it was for nothing. Cheer up

Anonymous said...

Except I didn't post that comment, Homer Paxton, you moron.

The real anon JC.

Stepford, I would be really nice if you had checked the IP and informed the paxtonian fool they didn't match, instead of letting it go through.

Steve said...

JC, I don't know how to check the IP for a comment in Blogger.

I thought some comments lately didn't come from you, but from someone else from Catallaxy. I don't know why they won't identify themselves...