I liked
Gopnik's article about the danger in Trump's appalling tweets, and it's worth reading it all. But I think these are the key paragraphs:
The trouble is that the damage done by Trump’s words is damage
enough. In a contestatory democracy—where the core notion, however
debased by overuse and however degraded by money and power, is that
political differences are settled by debate—words have, of necessity, a
quality not so much sacred as practical. They’re the currency of open
societies, which rest on the primary foundation of having exchanged
weapons for ideas. There’s a reason that the great crises of this
democracy have been met by an efflorescence of language, a reason that
we turn to Hamilton and Franklin and Lincoln and King not just for
wisdom about crises past but for a vocabulary for crises present. Words
are what governments with a liberal public face have to live by. We know
tyrannies by their temples; we know democracies through their tongues.
Trump’s
words don’t debate or even discredit. They degrade and delegitimize.
They’re insults so crude that it’s difficult to believe that anyone
could find them persuasive, but that are clearly intended to appeal to a
part of what is called the “base”—an unintentional, if somewhat
Shakespearean, pun. One miserable truth of humanity is that cruel
impulses are easy to awaken in large numbers of people, if they’re told
by those in power that those impulses are now acceptable, and the form
that such permission takes is invariably a reawakening of the language
of demonology.....
Trump, in maintaining that the opposition is not merely wrong but
criminal, not mistaken but illegitimate, undermines not a norm or a
manner or some stuffy curlicue of liberalism’s house rules; he assaults
its essence. We are shocked by Trump’s language not because we’re prim
but because we understand intuitively, instinctively, that the language
is itself an assault on the rule of law, not merely a prologue or
preface to it. It’s not a puff of air. It has real consequences. James
Comey registered this shock just the other morning on NPR: “President
Trump, I don’t follow him on Twitter, but I get to see his tweets
tweeted, I don’t know how many, but some tweets this past couple of days
that I should be in jail. The President of the United States just said
that a private citizen should be jailed. And I think the reaction of
most of us was, ‘Meh, that’s another one of those things.’ This is not
normal. This is not O.K. There’s a danger that we will become numb to
it, and we will stop noticing the threats to our norms.” To which one
might add only that it isn’t norms but premises that are being
undermined. Every time Trump calls his critics or political opponents
“crooks” or “slime balls,” it poisons the possibility for open debate.
1 comment:
you can see why Trump is Catallaxy's poster boy
He is pig ignorant, He boasts about skills he does not posses, he is a bully,
He degrades conversation. He constantly engages in abuse
He has no class at all. Indeed he does not understand social norms.
Post a Comment