Thursday, April 22, 2021

Dumb, unhealthy, angry.... and happy?

Some stuff on Twitter has got me thinking about that favourite topic:  How the Right Got Consumed by the Culture Wars and Went Nuts.

This, for example:

And this:


That article by Richard Hanania (who I don't know) briefly makes the point that lots of research has shown that people who say they are on the Right are happier than those on the Left.   And I used to think that made sense when I was younger - the motivation to social change that is typical of the Left seemed to me to come mainly from people from unhappy family backgrounds.  

But the typical anger profile has, in large part, flipped now.   Sure, on the Left, there's lot of angry emotion over identity politics, but not all of it is ill founded.   And comedy has moved to be completely liberal dominated.  Happy people laugh more, don't they?

I wonder - is social research into happiness (which I suspect is actually quite a slippery thing to measure accurately) lagging behind the current state of the Right?   Because you sure as hell don't get the impression from social and Right wing media that the current Trumpy/Murdoch led American Right (and those Australians who align with it) has been happy for years.   A boiling pot of resentment that their ideas are not overwhelmingly accepted (by and large) by media, academia, big business and the public - yes.   A vast echo chamber of resentment and conspiracy mongering to explain why they find they find themselves in a minority - yeah.  

I note that some on the Right who were eulogising Rush Limbaugh recently said how much humour was a part of his early career - but I suspect that in the last decade, as with Right wing media generally, the attempts at humour became less important and got pushed out by anger, resentment and conspiracy.  

So, does it come down to the question - to what degree can you be angry all the time, and still count yourself as "happy"?      

Things to ponder over...


4 comments:

Not Trampis said...

Oh Steve,
It is obvious,
They are happy being angry

TimT said...

No, comedians are one depressed bunch.

Steve said...

Yes, Tim: I've often remarked on how it's pretty much a given that you scratch a comedian and find a complete neurotic/depressed mess beneath the surface. There seem to be so few exceptions.

The political divide in comedy used to not be so clear - so people used to know that high profile comedian X supported Republicans, but people who voted Democrat could still find him or her funny.

But now - it's impossible to be a high profile Right wing supporter and still be funny. Because the Right has gone nuts. And, to be fair, identity politics and its complications has a role in it too.

TimT said...

Yes. I think for a lot of the past decade, too, the left has been very successful at divide and conquer tactics, drawing the support of sensible centrists away from the right.

The only high profile Republican comedian that comes to mind is Kelsey Grammer - or was.

Dave Chapelle is very good at challenging the left wing status quo and getting away with it. But I believe he remains a Democrat.