Allahpundit notes how Bill Maher has quickly fallen out of Left wing favour (and risen in Fox News esteem) due to his recent "I'm over COVID" complaints (which included, I believe, the nonsense position that he was not going to get a booster because - well, they used to say that two was enough, so how dare medical science change its mind during an evolving pandemic?) Maher has apparently gone on to complain about the Left going nuts in a more general sense. (I haven't watched the clip, but I see the screenshot features the "pregnant man" emoji which my daughter told me - with amusement - that Apple had just released.)
I've always been leery of Maher as a reliable political friend - too many libertarian instincts in him are probably at the heart of it.
And Allahpundit (and Maher) note that the problem is similar on the Right - a part of it goes nuts, and the "mainstream" stands around and fails to call it out. It's cowardice.
But it's somewhat galling that they don't (well, at least Allahpundit doesn't) explicitly say what is clear: the nuttiness of the Right is on topics that make it far, far more dangerous than the identity politics nuttiness on the Left.
The Leftist extreme, for example, thinks gender is completely a choice and former men who grew up with male bodies should face no discrimination when joining a women's competition. They get people de-platformed from Twitter and elsewhere for being mean to transgender folk, and vow never to read Harry Potter again. They virtually beg for social media confirmation that they now look "hot" in their new body. Academics, and sometimes researchers, do get very unfairly targeted if they are perceived to not be completely supportive of the agenda. And in Australia, the patently obvious campaign to upgrade old Aboriginal society to the status of "civilisation" and sophistication continues apace, with sceptical and realistic voices rarely raised.
The nutty Right, on the other hand, makes death threats to election workers, scientists and doctors continually, both on social media and directly, based on bad faith conspiracy promoted for greed by both big and small media outlets. In America, they have no commitment to democracy and enabling greater participation in it. They wanted to overturn a fair election, and rallied chanting death to politicians who thwarted their plan. They do not believe in climate change and would happily burn every last bit of coal because they don't believe scientists and the evidence before their eyes. They are happy to demonise both immigrants and their political opponents as being inherently evil.
It's clear that the conspiracy belief of the Right is priming material for Right wing terrorist acts: its seems more by luck than anything else that there hasn't been a major incident for a while.
So yes, I would like more on the Left to speak up about extreme and unrealistic views on identity politics and culture war issues - but let's not pretend there is an equivalence of the seriousness of the problem on both sides.
Update: I've watched the Maher clip and it is pretty weak stuff. Yes, he's upset with identity politics, but also goes on at greater length with a general libertarian whine that Democrats want to regulate too much.
1 comment:
They virtually beg for social media confirmation that they now look "hot" in their new body.
I know it's not your central point, but I have seen this exact thing happen several times, it's very strange and it seems like an out-and-out form of denial. I think partly this is because they're generally folks who have suffered from extreme anxiety or depression and have been treating it for years with 'positivity' - so they are being positive about their new look. And also because, as you've said somewhere, it is a way of at least externally dispelling doubts about their transition.
Post a Comment