Tuesday, January 28, 2020

Bats and racism

A few points about China, coronavirus, and racism:

*   does Sinclair Davidson not mind at all that his blog for old fools is crammed with comments using "chinks" for Chinese since the outbreak of the coronavirus.   He certainly doesn't care enough to insert his own objection into threads or posts - not that I can see.  Update:   doesn't he teach at a tertiary institution that has lots of high fee paying Chinese students?    Wouldn't RMIT find this lack of control over his own blog concerning (remembering that commenters are forever complaining that certain words are on a "ban" filter that stops their whole comment ever being published.)  In other words, he could stop the casual and repeated use of a word almost universally regarded as offensive/racist if he wanted, but he doesn't.  Why?  

*  I had missed this about the "bat video":
As news of the Wuhan virus spread online, one video became emblematic of its claimed origin: It showed a young Chinese woman, supposedly in Wuhan, biting into a virtually whole bat as she held the creature up with chopsticks. Media outlets from the Daily Mail to RT promoted the video, as did a number of prominent extremist bloggers such as Paul Joseph Watson. Thousands of Twitter users blamed supposedly “dirty” Chinese eating habits—in particular the consumption of wildlife—for the outbreak, said to have begun at a so-called wet market that sold animals in Wuhan, China.

There was just one problem. The video wasn’t set in Wuhan at all, where bat isn’t a delicacy. It wasn’t even from China. Instead it showed Wang Mengyun, the host of an online travel show, eating a dish in Palau, a Pacific island nation. Sampling the bat was simply an addition to the well-trodden cannon of adventurism and enthusiasm for unusual foods that numerous American chefs and travel hosts have shown in the past.
That's from a Foreign Policy opinion piece, that needs a subscription to read the rest of the article, which goes on to talk about how the idea of Chinese being dirty disease carriers has a long racist history.  Unfortunately, though I cannot read the whole article.

*  I have made comments over the last couple of years about how I wish that the Chinese (and other nearby Asian cultures) could get over the traditional medicine ideas that eating certain animals carries certain specific health benefits, usually (I think) based on the perceived spirit characteristic of the animal.   The harm I referred to, though, is to the endangered wild animals caught up in this quasi magical belief system.  I don't really care if people eat something wild that is not endangered (insects or rats, for example), although I guess I have a general bias towards the idea that eating farmed animals generally is a safer thing to do from a "risk of catching exotic disease" point of view.  (Even then, a lot depends on the hygiene in the farms too, I guess.)

In any event, I don't see an objection to the eating of endangered animals for a fanciful health benefit is a racist thing:  just in case anyone was going to throw that at me.


6 comments:

GMB said...

Probably Soon is over there using Chinese slang terms as deep cover. Chinese people can see us as smelling bad being as we tend to be more hairy than they are and they can smell the dairy products on our sweat. I'm here sweating all the time and probably clear through until April. Believe me I shower often. But if I want friends who are Asian girls all over again I better be perfumed up because those girls have noses like bloodhounds.

Nonetheless there is a scintilla of truth to the idea that the Chinese can be a breeding ground for new viruses and I believe its to do with part of their country being deficient in Selenium. Though today the deep state will be trying all manner of population control and ways to sicken all of us in general and the Chinese people particularly.

We all better have a good stash of selenium, super high dose vitamin D from overseas. And if you can afford it a big box of lipisomal vitamin C. Also start building up the iodine in your system and maybe even think about colloidal silver. Think about leaning your be uphill in some way, so that you can breathe better if you can barely get out of bed for a few days.

Viruses don't normally have the genetic sophistication to hurt people all that much. But this one appears to be going straight for the lungs. If you can keep breathing you will pull through.

Jason Soon said...

Selenium?? Not the take I expected from you Graeme, why is China deficient in selenium?

Jason Soon said...

hey Graeme what do you think about the conspiracy theory that the live food markets are being blamed for an accidental leak of a bioweapon being developed by the Chinese govt? https://www.news.com.au/lifestyle/health/health-problems/mystery-lab-next-to-coronavirus-epicentre/news-story/3e5a32fe77263fe8ca81b091cc8d9c42

Jason Soon said...

more on the Chinese bat girl https://www.news.com.au/lifestyle/food/food-warnings/chinese-influencer-wang-mengyun-aka-bat-soup-girl-breaks-silence/news-story/63ef0cec5b6d448d1843e2e1bcadb14d

GMB said...

I think there are areas of selenium deficient soils in China and that can make China a bit of a breeding ground for nasty lurgies.

In terms of that conspiracy theory, well yes its possible. The situation is murky with a lot of smoke-blowing. You hide a real conspiracy behind 3 fake ones and its just too murky to tell what is going on right now.

But this is not the deep state virus to kill us all. Because its only a single virus. If they want to thin our numbers down they will have a cocktail of nasties.

The other thing is that the Chinese aren't the big conspiracy types. Its more likely that the Deep State would run a trial balloon and put it near to the lab, using the lab as a cover story. But then again anyone can make mistakes.

Something fishy is going on because otherwise the smoke-blowing machine wouldn't be running so hard. But the smoke-blowing machine is deep state and not Chinese.

GMB said...

"It may just be a coincidence.
But the deadly coronavirus outbreak now sweeping the world began 30km from China’s most advanced viral research laboratories – the Wuhan Institute.
The Washington Times quoted former Israeli intelligence officer Dany Shoham as claiming The Wuhan Institute of Virology is part of a secret biological weapons program."

You look at the map and obviously its no co-incidence. So we want to stop this coincidence bullshit just for starters. And note that its an Israeli trying to frame the story. So he's trying to make you think that its an escape from the facility. Note what this fellow says is not unscientific. But the framing of a single hypothesis is. So they are trying to push this story of a coverup.

Its just like the Iran shootdown of that plane which turned out to be a forced era, setting up the plane to look like a missile by buggering up its responder. And having a fellow filming on the ground so as to ensure that everyone saw that it was taken down by missiles. That was a Western crime and not an Iranian mistake.

Well this is probably an elaborate sting coming out of the West. Making it look like the Chinese are to blame but setting them up for it. Catallaxy has discussed this option. The West has now been colonised by Israeli tactics as their ongoing model of doing things.