This lengthy article in The Guardian about a huge amount of infighting going on at Melbourne University on the issue of aboriginal studies and who gets appointed to positions would clearly be grounds for some good satirical fictionalised treatment. I'm casting my mind back to A Very Peculiar Practice, from the late 1980's, as the kind of thing I would like. (I wonder how that would play now, if I rewatched it; I do remember enjoying it at the time.) But the problem is, no one would be game to try this now. Not unless it was very, very sympathetic to the Aboriginal characters.
Dare I say, I don't have any doubt at all that there are many positions in indigenous academia which deserve to be cut. I mean, I read Sandy O'Sullivan's twitter feed just to aggravate myself, where I learn about all sort of esoteric talks and projects and overseas travel that are useful for keeping indigenous academics talking amongst themselves about how important their work is, rather than engaging with he rest of us, which is (I suppose) some sort of benefit to society. At what cost to more useful funding, though?
Here are some extracts:
The University of Melbourne
has come under fire for appointing non-Indigenous academics to senior
roles focused on Aboriginal studies, at the same time as acknowledging
it is “ill-equipped” to handle allegations of institutional racism.
The fresh criticism follows the resignation of Dr Eddie Cubillo
– a Larrakia, Wadjigan and Central Arrernte man – from his role as
part-time associate dean and senior fellow at the university’s
prestigious Melbourne Law School (MLS).
Cubillo
continues to lead the university’s Indigenous Law and Justice Hub but
alleged the law school was “the most culturally unsafe place” he’d
worked.
In
an email sent to staff last week, the deputy vice-chancellor
(Indigenous), Barry Judd, said Cubillo’s experiences showed current
processes were “ill-equipped” to deal with “the complex issues raised by
allegations of racism in the workplace”.
“As an organisation we have to do better,” he wrote.
And:
The Indigenous Knowledge Institute, founded in
late 2020 to advance Indigenous research and education, is headed by
Aaron Corn, who is a “long-term collaborator” with Indigenous leaders.
A
University of Melbourne (UoM) academic who wanted to remain anonymous
said the appointment of a non-Indigenous academic as the inaugural head
of a department wholly dedicated to Indigenous knowledge was “one of the
big catalysts” for the recent exits of First Nations staff.
“There was no shortage of [Indigenous] talent and it wasn’t a one-off,” they said.
Zena
Cumpston, a Barkandji woman and former research fellow at the
university, said it was common for non-Indigenous “experts” rather than
Indigenous academics to be placed in senior roles advising on community
and teaching Indigenous subjects.
Cumpston quit in August last year. She said she
experienced significant mental distress linked to her treatment at the
university and said she felt that anyone who spoke out against hiring
policies was “carved off as an individual problem”.
While
she was in the science faculty, Cumpston was asked to join its
Indigenous advisory body for no extra pay. She was shocked to find the
advisory panel was mostly comprised of non-Indigenous academics.
“Our
elders and communities have fought for these upper-level positions for
decades – the fundamental basics of self-determination – and here’s a
trend for positions with the word ‘Indigenous’ to be filled by
‘experts’, taking us back decades,” Cumpston said.
And:
Nic Radoll worked for seven months at the
University of Melbourne as its Indigenous engagement and outreach
coordinator before resigning late in 2022.
Radoll,
a non-binary and queer Anaiwan person, said it was the “worst
experience” of their career. They sent an email when resigning arguing
Indigenous staff were under-appreciated and subjects were labelled as
being “Indigenous-run” despite key decisions being made by
non-Indigenous staff.
“When I raised issues … I was told that I ‘don’t
exhibit any leadership qualities and will never go anywhere’ at the
university,” they said.
“I was told to ‘reduce
my expectations’ and that ‘it takes time to make change’ so I should
just do what I get told to do. It’s a killer for mental health.”
Nic is interviewed on this Youtube video. I feel mean in saying it, but yeah, "leadership qualities" are a bit hard to detect when you speak with that upwards inflection at the end of every second or third sentence.
Now, to be fair, it's not only this area of academia I would cut back if I were Benevolent Dictator of Australia.
RMIT's Blockchain Innovation Hub is the Right wing equivalent of Indigenous academia - keeps them off the street, developing arcane terminology with which to convince themselves it's a field worth pursuing, and (thankfully) off the TV or anywhere else.
Update: I note that Aaron Corn, who gets a mention in one of the extracts above, had a book out earlier this year co-authored with Marcia Langton. That would indicate that she doesn't have a big problem with his being appointed to head the Indigenous Knowledge Institute.
Update 2: Oh good. The professor is about to go on another junket, having just returned from a trip that took her to American and England: