There's a funny column by Marina Hyde at The Guardian that points to something pretty obvious:
Ruining a country near you soon: the beta males who think they’re alphas
After a week in which paddle-less Britain has found itself once more
caught in dangerous transatlantic currents, it’s clear that there are
two kinds of political men. Strong men and weak men. Which one is our
most likely next prime minister? I’m afraid Boris Johnson is the worst
kind: he’s a weak man who thinks he’s a strong man. See also selective
antiracist Jeremy Corbyn, whose unshakeable conviction that he hasn’t
been wrong in several decades has left him stubbornly incapable of being
the bigger person. See also gratefully submissive Donald Trump fanboy
Nigel Farage, who has spent much of the past three years hanging wanly around Washington
on the off-chance of a half-hour 6pm burger with the alpha male to his
beta. And see also Donald Trump himself, the leader of the free world,
who spent about 48 hours this week tweeting like some homicidal
11-year-old Justin Bieber fan about the leaked comments of the British ambassador. Who, apparently, we now let him pick. More on toxic insecurity’s poster boy shortly.
This whole talk of alpha males brings to mind the changing popular image of masculinity in my lifetime: it is genuinely weird, is it not, that the progression of popular perception of strong masculinity went from, if Hollywood was a guide, the "gentle but strong" masculinity of characters played by Gregory Peck, Jimmy Stewart, Paul Newman and Robert Redford (most of whom were, I think, liberals in politics in real life) to the fathead, muscle bound, shoot-their-way-out-of -trouble image of Sylvester Stallone, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Bruce Willis and perhaps even Mel Gibson. What exactly was going on in the 1980's into the 1990's? A last hurrah for over-the-top masculinity that the ageing support base for Donald Trump still longs for now? I felt it was weird at the time - how even toy manufacturers came out with muscled up versions of cartoon or movie characters (muscle bound Luke Skywalker, for God's sake.)
And the funniest thing is how the wingnut Right's figureheads for a return to the good old days of generic national strength and masculinity are both overweight, buffoon haired, patently bad husbands that are nothing like what normal people used to associate with an image of confident masculinity.
As for Boris Johnson, Marina writes:
Great leaders show, rather than tell, their skills. Yet Johnson never
lets up with telling people that he is not “defeatist”, that he will
“put some lead in the collective pencil”, that “energy” is needed, that
what the EU really fears is a big strong man like him. Mm. I hear they
talk of little else in the 27 European capitals. “O Fates, please spare
us the dreaded ‘positive energy’ of a guy internationally ridiculed as
the worst foreign secretary in memory; and the unplayable charm of a
surprisingly indifferent orator who knows the Latin for ‘can we just
take out the backstop?’”
And Johnson does know Latin, as he never misses a chance to remind us.
No one could accuse him of wearing his learning lightly – or, indeed,
wearing any of it lightly. Witness his excruciating promise to reach out
to something he pointedly referred to as “Oppidan Britain”.
To which the increasingly despairing response has to be: YES YES! I
KNOW WHAT SCHOOL YOU WENT TO! I KNOW WHAT HOUSE YOU WERE IN! I KNOW YOU
GOT A SECOND CLASS CLASSICS DEGREE! I KNOW THIS SOMEHOW ENDS WITH YOU
CONSIGNING OUR ENTIRE COUNTRY TO THE CATACOMBS THEN BEATING US TO DEATH
WITH YOUR RELATIVELY MIDDLEBROW ACHIEVEMENTS! But mate: you are 55 –
FIFTY-FIVE – years old. How, how can you possibly still be wanking on
about any of this, in public, as though it was still the best thing
you’ve ever done? Can it really be because it was? [Spoiler: yes.]...
...He may use longer words, but Johnson’s sledgehammer self-admiration does not differ materially from the US president’s diurnal reminders that he is a strong, good-looking and very stable genius.
Because I don't see as much of Boris Johnson, I don't have any clear idea of how insecure he comes across, but Marina makes a good argument that he is as bad as Trump.
Trump's insecurity, narcissism and lack of knowledge on so many issues is plain to see to everyone except
(apparently) his base base. Or, as might be more likely, it's a case that perhaps half of his base see it but nonetheless celebrate it. Just as he embodies a poor person's caricature of what it would be like to live rich (gold toilet - cool), his Tweeting behaviour might be seen as ridiculous on one level, but they get a proxy
thrill at seeing a jerk being able to say
anything and no one can stop him. You sense this celebratory attitude at Catallaxy all the time - along with their admissions that they comment there specifically in order to say things they cannot say in front of their spouses, or at work without getting into trouble (for being obnoxious).
As I have said before, this is actually a sign of frustration at being losers on issues they identify as part of a culture
war - on matters of changing attitudes to sexuality, gender roles,
masculinity and environmentalism. Unfortunately, though, it is at the cost of good government and policy for everyone.
And before I go, some funny comments that followed that Guardian column:
The juxtaposition of Trump MAGA guys banging on about masculinity and Trump is so funny.
They spent eight years throwing a fit at Obama being effeminate
because he drank a Cafe Latte, but Obama was probably a pretty good
example of what an "alpha male" would look like, if such a thing
existed.
Trump, meanwhile, is a guy who has the personality of a bitchy
cheerleader from a dated romcom, tweeting all day about how Anna
Wintour's party was soooooo lame since he wasn't invited, or bullying
Rosie O'Donnell for being fat.
But you have all these men saying "oh yeah, so good to have a Real
Man in charge doing Real Man stuff. Finally!", as their hero obsessively
messages Robert Pattinson once more imploring him not to take back
Kristen Stewart.
And this:
Worth noting that every second one of
these "alpha" guys is in hock to some "masculinity" guru like Peteron
who is is selling their followers some sort of masculinity supplement,
masculinity guide, special diet to make them more masculine or all of
the above. This is what alpha males do, you see: buy books on how to be
manly and take snake oil diet pills.
As women, we find it irrestistible when men are constantly whining
about how they're disempowered by feminism, somehow. Even hotter is when
they spend all day online and have obsessive faddy diets. So manly.
Grrrr...
Funny because it's true - from Alex Jones to Ben Shapiro with the "diet supplements".
I'm surprised Sinclair Davidson hasn't endorsed his own range of supplements, now that I think of it.